From A-Legitimacy to Legal Cognisability: Human Trafficking and the Protection of Wild Berry Pickers
My research, published by Oikeus in December 2025, examines how the identification of human trafficking can strengthen the protection of foreign workers in vulnerable positions in Finland, using the case of wild berry picking as an example. Although the structural problems associated with wild berry picking have long been recognised by public authorities, they have not been treated as a systemic social issue requiring robust protective measures or legislation aimed at preventing exploitation. Berry picking has instead been framed as an activity akin to tourism, presumed to benefit both companies and pickers, and shortcomings have therefore been addressed primarily through cooperation between authorities and industry actors. The choice of regulatory tools has also reflected whose voices have been heard and who has been able to shape the public narrative.
A shift occurred only when pickers’ experiences began to be assessed within criminal proceedings as potential instances of human trafficking. A trafficking conviction and extensive investigations altered how the pickers’ position was understood. Once the phenomenon was reframed in the language of human trafficking, the pickers came to be recognised as victims of a serious crime, entitled to protection under international treaties and EU legislation. This legal turn rendered their experiences legally cognisable and generated pressure for legislative reform. International scrutiny reinforced this momentum: Thai authorities publicly highlighted the precarious situation of Thai pickers and demanded more effective Finnish measures to prevent exploitation. In the summer of 2024, Thailand temporarily barred its citizens from travelling to Finland, prompting political negotiations between the two states.
The Finnish government led by Prime Minister Orpo commissioned a further assessment comparing two regulatory models: seasonal employment and self‑employment. The assessment recommended an employment-based model, even though it was expected to increase business costs and lead some operators to withdraw from the sector. The justification rested on the view that foreign pickers could not reasonably be expected to manage the obligations associated with self-employment. In May 2024, the government decided that wild berry picking would henceforth be organised as seasonal employment. Berry picking would no longer be treated as tourism; instead, companies would be required to hire pickers recruited from outside the EU and EEA for seasonal work as employees. The principal aim of the legislative reform is to prevent exploitation and trafficking, and the preparatory documents explicitly refer to EU anti‑trafficking law (amended in 2024) and the UN Trafficking Protocol.
The research is grounded in the theoretical framework of a-legitimacy, developed by Kevät Nousiainen and her colleagues, and Jean‑François Lyotard’s theory of the differend (Lyotard: The Differend. Phrases in Dispute, 1989). A-legitimacy denotes practices that are neither clearly accepted nor explicitly rejected, yet nonetheless generate vulnerability and expose individuals to exploitation. Wild berry picking under the tourist visa system exemplifies such an a-legitimate practice: it was not prohibited, but neither was it subject to clear legal endorsement. As a result, pickers’ position remained at the margins of legal regulation, and their vulnerability was not recognised as warranting protection until the criminal justice system intervened.
Lyotard’s differend theory explains why the pickers’ experiences were not legally cognisable. A differend arises when a group’s experiences cannot be articulated within the prevailing legal or linguistic framework. In the case of wild berry pickers, their accounts of exploitation and vulnerability did not fit within the conceptual boundaries of the tourism-based model. Berry picking was portrayed as economically beneficial and mutually advantageous, and the pickers’ marginal position was not understood as a context of serious exploitation or trafficking. Their experiences were therefore not legally recognisable until criminal proceedings provided a new interpretive frame.
The naming of the phenomenon as human trafficking within criminal proceedings functioned, in Lyotard’s sense, as a linguistic turn that transformed the meaning of the pickers’ experiences. Once their situation was described through the vocabulary of trafficking, their position shifted from the grey zone of a-legitimacy into the domain of enforceable legal protection. The trafficking definition made their vulnerability visible and legally relevant, imposing obligations on the state to protect them under international and EU law. The transformation also reshaped public understanding of the pickers’ position and generated demands for legislative measures to prevent exploitation.
The research concludes that intervention by the criminal justice system and the recognition of trafficking have significant implications. The conditions under which migrant labour is recruited and employed can be reshaped so that exploitation is no longer regarded as an inherent or tolerated feature of the system. Achieving this requires the state to impose obligations on employers and companies using foreign labour, to monitor compliance effectively, to investigate suspected exploitation and trafficking, and to provide assistance to victims. At the same time, the effectiveness of anti-trafficking efforts depends on how trafficking is defined and who is deemed entitled to protection.
The research adopts the view that bringing wild berry picking within the scope of the Seasonal Workers Act may not fully eliminate trafficking in the sector, given the strong economic incentives involved. The employment relationship has nevertheless strengthened pickers’ legal protection and enabled the authorities to monitor compliance with terms of employment. The requirement applies, however, only to those entering Finland for seasonal work. After the Ministry for Foreign Affairs refused most visa applications from Thai pickers in 2026, berry companies recruited foreign nationals already living in Finland, many of them international students arriving from outside the EU and EEA. They pick under the Berry Act (487/2021) without an employment relationship, and some have reported inadequate accommodation, recruitment fee-type charges and loss of income.
In the terms used in the research, their position resembles a-legitimacy. Their activity is lawful, but they lack the protection of an employment relationship. As with the tourist visa system, picking is often framed as a voluntary source of extra income, which can make exploitation difficult to articulate. The research suggests that protection should not depend on exploitation first surfacing in criminal proceedings. This requires legislation that prevents exploitation more effectively than the Berry Act currently does.
As the research concludes, the effectiveness of anti-trafficking measures depends on who is considered entitled to protection. The legitimacy and utility of the anti-trafficking framework will be judged by whether it protects the victims and prevents the exploitation of those in vulnerable positions.
About the Author

Venla Roth is Professor of Practice at the Faculty of Law, University of Turku, where she convenes a specialisation course on preventing and combating trafficking in human beings and teaches law students about law and social change: how social change comes about, what it takes and how lawyers can be part of it. She is Finland’s Government Anti-Trafficking Coordinator at the Ministry of Justice, where she prepares the national anti-trafficking action plans, oversees their implementation and chairs expert working groups, and handles Finland’s anti-trafficking cooperation in the Nordic Council of Ministers, the Council of the Baltic Sea States and the EU. She has sat on the European Commission’s Expert Group on Trafficking in Human Beings and on the OSCE/ODIHR advisory group on national referral mechanisms, and worked as an expert for the European Parliament, the Commission and EIGE. Before the Ministry, she led a team at the Office of the Non-Discrimination Ombudsman. She holds a doctorate in law from 2010.
